House Favorites
Online Only Specials
Provolone Cheese
1 Pound of Sliced Provolone Cheese
$2.99
Shredded Mozzarella Cheese
1 Pound of Shredded Mozzarella Cheese
$2.99
Specialty Items/Specials
Homemade Fried Pierogies
6 Deep Fried Homemade Pierogies filled with cheddar cheese, potatoes, and onions. Come with Sour Cream
$8.99
Party Platters/Trays
Mini Pepperoni Balls - 60 ct. Tray
60 of our fresh made mini pepperoni balls Comes with pizza sauce and ranch dressing Made day of pickup. **24 hours advance notice minimum**
$30.00
Everyday Specials
X-Large Pizza & 24 Wings Special
Wing flavor split will be 12/12 unless otherwise specified by you in notes
$39.99
Medium Pizza & 12 Wings Special
$25.99
Two X-Large Pizzas Special
$24.99
X-Large One Topping Pizza & Small Antipasto Special
$20.99
2# Boneless Wings Special
$19.99
Any Hot Sub & Appetizer Special
$13.99
Wednesday Specials
X-Large One Topping Pizza, 12 Wings & 1 Lb. Boneless Wings Special
$35.99
Two Sub Special
$12.99
Deli - Sliced Luncheon Meat & Cheese
Boiled Ham
$4.99
Virginia Baked Ham
$5.99
Hot Ham
$5.99
Ham off the Bone
$5.99
Pepperoni
Pepperoni is presliced.
$5.99
Oven Roasted Turkey Breast
$6.99
Smith Bologna (Regular Only - No Garlic)
$6.99
Roast Beef
$8.99
Hard Salami
Item Is Presliced thin
$5.99
Swiss Cheese
$5.99
Pepperjack Cheese
$5.99
Mozzarella Cheese
$5.99
Yellow American Cheese
$5.99
Provolone Cheese
$5.99
Horseradish Cheese
$5.99
Pizza
Personal 7" Pizza
$6.99
Medium 14" Cheese Pizza
$13.99
Extra Large 16" Cheese Pizza
$15.99
Chicken/Wings
Chicken Wings
$9.52
Boneless Wings
$11.99
Chicken Tenders
$10.99
Classic Hot Subs
Turkey Sub
Turkey, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing or Mayonnaise
$8.99
Meatball Sub
Meatballs, Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese
$8.99
Roast Beef Sub
Roast Beef, Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing or Mayonnaise
$8.99
Chicken Tender Sub
Chicken Tenders, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing
$8.99
BLT Sub
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise
$8.99
Italian Combo Sub
Ham, Hard Salami, Hot Ham, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing
$8.99
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing
$8.99
Pizza Sub
Pizza Sauce, Pepperoni, Mozzarella Cheese
$8.99
Pepperoni & Cheese Sub
Pepperoni, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise or Italian Dressing
$8.99
Signature Hot Subs
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Chicken Tenders, Mild Buffalo Sauce, Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomatoes
$8.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Chicken Tenders, Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese
$8.99
Chicken Cordon Blue Sub
Ham, Chicken Tenders, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise
$8.99
Vegetarian Sub
American & Provolone Cheeses, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing
$8.99
Chicken Bacon Swiss Sub
Chicken Tenders, Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise
$8.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
Chicken Tenders, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Ranch Dressing
$8.99
Philly Cheesesteak Sub
Philly Steak, Mozzarella Cheese, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms
$8.99
Nightmare Sub
Ham, Hot Ham, Pepperjack Cheese, Pepperoni, Onions, Banana Peppers, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Italian Dressing
$8.99
Ham & Turkey Club
Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Swiss, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise
$8.99
Grilled Chicken Club
Grilled, Chicken, Bacon, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayonnaise
$8.99
Philly Chicken Sub
Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms
$8.99
Appetizers
Provolone Triangles (4)
$5.99
Chicken Nuggets (1/2 Lb.)
$5.99
Mushrooms (1/2 Lb.)
$5.99
Hot Shots (20)
They're Back! Hot Pepper Cheese Cubes
$5.99
Cauliflower (1/2Lb.)
$5.99
Mini Tacos (10)
$5.99
Onion Rings (1/2Lb.)
$5.99
Regular Fries (1/2Lb.)
$1.99
Spicy Fries (1/2Lb.)
$1.99
Zucchini (1/2Lb.)
$5.99
Mozzarella Sticks (5)
$5.99
Ranch Fries (1/2Lb.)
$1.99
Pepperoni Balls
$1.59
Chicken & Fry Basket
$7.99
Chicken Tenders
$9.99
Cream Cheese Poppers (5)
$5.99
Pizza Logs (4)
$5.99
Salads
Antipasto Salad
Small serves about 1-2 Large serves about 6-8 Extra Large about 10 - 15+
$9.99
Grilled Chicken Salad
$9.99
Deli Subs (Cold)
10" Deli Sub
$7.99
Tuesday Specials
Any Two Appetizer Special
$9.99
Pizza Special
$19.99
Thursday Specials
Thursday Chicken Wing Special
$7.92
Medium One Topping Pizza Special
$11.99
Boneless Wing Special
$14.99
Sunday Specials
X-Large One Topping Pizza, 12 Wings & 1 Lb. Boneless Wings Special
$35.99
Any Two Subs Special
$12.99
Monday Specials
Boneless Wing Special
$14.99
Medium 14" Pizza
$11.99
Friday Specials
X-Large One Topping Pizza & 24 Wings Special
Flavor split will be 12/12 unless otherwise specified by you in notes
$36.99
Chicken Tenders Special
$12.99
Saturday Specials
Any Two Appetizer Special
$9.99
Any Two XL Pizza Special
$19.99
Gary's Superette
Looking for something good to eat? Try the best pizzas in Erie. Gary's Superette remains one of the most popular in Erie thanks to its fresh offerings and classic pizzas. Give their menu a try and see what all the fuss is about. If you're feeling hungry, don't hesitate. Enjoy the top dishes Erie has to offer. This restaurant is known for Homemade Fried Pierogies. Try it for yourself and see what the fuss is about. This reliable restaurant has been a Slice partner for 3 years. You can count on them providing something tasty. Make takeout easy with curbside pickup from Gary's Superette. Don't forget to check for deals at Gary's Superette. You can make your money stretch further with their regular special offers. Gary's Superette accepts credit cards. That makes it easy to get your pizza sooner.
Full Hours